Resources

Bouayad v. Normandy Ins. Co., et al,___So.3d___(Fla. 7/9/26) Arising Out Of/Workplace Assaults Bill Rogner The claimant was GM of a car rental business located in a hotel near Orlando Int’l Airport. He was shot several times in a dimly lit outdoor walkway by an unknown assailant. Thereafter, he stated to a guest that “Robert did this.” Although evidence suggested the assailant might be Robert Aponte, who had a vendetta against the claimant’s son, no concrete evidence existed that the assailant... View More

No DCA decisions for the month of August. View More

JCC Stanton (Orlando) (Amy Raub / Rex Hurley) (9-9-2026) – Denied all claims based on misrepresentation. Pro se claimant. The JCC found the claimant was not credible based on being very evasive during questioning, in addition to false statements in social media postings about his capabilities such as the inability to walk upstairs, among other examples. The JCC found that since the claimant was not a credible witness, his testimony could not be trusted as truthful. Regarding misrepresentation, the E/C’s... View More

JCC Sancerni (Jacksonville) (Dino Jahic) (9-8-2026) – Denied all benefits.  Pro se claimant. The only medical records filed by the claimant consisted of four pages of hospital records, but there was no expert medical testimony as to the claimant’s physical injuries and their causal relationship with the accident. The claimant failed to meet her burden that the accident was the major contributing cause of any resulting injury, or to establish a causal connection and/or medical necessity for the medical benefits... View More

JCC Grindal (Tampa) – Andy Borah (9-2-2026) – Denied claim for authorization and evaluation with Dr. Spencer Smith. The claimant sought authorization for an evaluation with his treating orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Spencer Smith, arguing that his ongoing severe low-back and sacral pain warranted further orthopedic review beyond his current care with pain management specialist Dr. Arpit Patel. The E/C asserted that a return to Dr. Smith was not medically necessary because the claimant’s fractures had healed normally and his current... View More