Witherell v. Hernando County Sheriff’s Office / FSRMF

HR Law Cases

JCC Anthony (Tampa) (Rex Hurley & Tim Stanton) (10-15-2026) – Denied all benefits. The claimant was hired by Hernando County Sheriff’s Office in 2011 and underwent a pre-employment physical.  On 11/13/25, he was in his patrol car and suffered a stroke. While in the hospital he was given Lisinopril for BP control. Dr. Steven Borzak performed an IME record review for the claimant. Dr. Borzak diagnosed the claimant with a subcortical stroke. He was not sure if the claimant was diagnosed with hypertension at discharge for his stroke. Dr. Borzak opined the claimant should see a neurologist for the stroke and an internist for hypertension. On cross, Dr. Borzak testified the cause of the claimant’s stroke was not known. He did not know the extent to which BP contributed to the stroke. Dr. Rochelle Knowles became the claimant’s PCP in December 2025. The claimant was still taking Lisinopril when he first saw her, but she did not note he had hypertension, she noted he had controlled hypertension with Lisinopril when she first saw him. As of 6/26/26, the claimant still had a diagnosis of essential hypertension although he had no complaints at the visit. On cross, Dr. Knowles testified that the first time the diagnosis of hypertension appeared in her notes was 2/27/26. She confirmed that the claimant was hospitalized for a stroke. The E/C stipulated the claimant was in the protected class and successfully underwent a pre-employment physical that did not show heart disease or hypertension. However, the E/C asserted the claimant did not establish he suffered a covered condition and/or the condition caused a disability. The JCC held the claimant failed to demonstrate entitlement to benefits for three reasons. First, the claimant failed to show he has hypertension now or that he had hypertension on the date of accident. Second, even if the claimant had hypertension, the reason he was disabled on the date of the accident was only related to the stroke. Third, the claimant did not demonstrate that the stroke was caused by hypertension. Alternatively, the JCC held the claimant failed to demonstrate that the MCC of the stroke was his employment. Therefore, all benefits were denied.   Click here to view Order